Root 66 by Miles

Puzzle explanation

This is one possible solution path. √66 = √2×√3×√11 ≈ 8.1 isn’t a rational number, meaning there’s no integer value of H that can make H√66 an integer. Multiplying out (B + C√66)(E + F√66) gives (BE + 66CF) + (BF + CE)√66 = G + H√66; the integer terms must be equal, so BE + 66CF = G. Having no zeros or repeated digits, all the BCEF and G values given by clues are at least 1234 and at most 9876.

The clues for y and t involve the square roots of I and D, so to give an integer (rational) result they must be square digits, ie two of {1, 4, 9}, and the product DI is one of {4, 9, 36}. Clue p = (DI − NO)(S + T)A + R means (DI − NO) = (p − R)/A/(S + T), for which the minimum is (1234 − 6)/9/(8 + 7) ≈ 9.1. So the minimum for DI is 10 + 1×2 = 12, which means DI = 36 with {D, I} = {4, 9} in some order, and NO ≤ 26.

The digit 1 can’t be T, because then the maximum for clue k would be (6 + 4 + 1A + 8×7 − 2 − 3)9 = 558, too small; if A is 1 then k ≤ (6 + 4 + 51 + 8×7 − 2 − 3)9 = 594, still too small. If R is 1 then in clue o the term (1O − √36) makes the answer negative; if O is 1 then o ≤ (6 + 5)7(81 − √36) = 154, also too small. If U is 1 then p ≤ 3×1T + (7 + 6 + 9)8 + 5 = 184, too small. If S is 1 then u ≤ 8(1T + 7×6 + 5) + 9 = 393, too small. The only letter left is N = 1, which leaves 235678 for the letters AORSTU in some order.

From clue n we have (1 + I)T = n/(US) + (A + R)D. If I is 4, the maximum for the right-hand side is 9876/(2×3) + (7 + 8)9 = 1781 but that would leave T ≥ 5 and 55 = 3125 is too big, so T is one of {2, 3}. (If I is 9, the maximum is a bit lower and we have 10T, and 105 = 100000 is even bigger.) If T is 2, then q < 8(82 + 8×8 + 1) + 9 = 1041, too small; therefore T = 3. Clue c contains TI added and multiplied with other things; 39 = 19683 would make c far too big, so I = 4 and D = 9.

Now one of the remaining letters AORSU is 2. If it’s A then k < (8 + 4 + 32 + 8×8 − 5 − 1)9 = 711, which is too small. If it’s S then u < 8(23 + 8×8 + 1) + 9 = 593, also too small. If it’s U then p < 8×23 + (8 + 8 + 4)8 + 1 = 225, too small again. If it’s O then o is (A + S)3(R2 − 6), with ASR from the set 5678; if R is 5 the maximum possible is (8 + 7)3(52 − 6) = 855, too small; if R is 6 then 62 − 6 = 30 would make o end in 0; the remaining options are {(5 + 6)3(72 − 6) = 1419, (5 + 8)3(72 − 6) = 1677, (6 + 8)3(72 − 6) = 1806, (5 + 6)3(82 − 6) = 1914, (5 + 7)3(82 − 6) = 2088, (6 + 7)3(82 − 6) = 2262}, all of which have a repeated digit or 0. Therefore O isn’t 2, which makes R = 2.

We now have AOSU = 5678 in some order. For d we have 36(1O×S + A + U)2 = 72(S + A + U) = 72(26 − O); the options are {72(26 − 5) = 1512, 72(26 − 6) = 1440, 72(26 − 7) = 1368, 72(26 − 8) = 1296}, and to avoid a repeated digit O must be one of {7, 8}. Also, e = (2AOU + 1)9 = (2×1680/S + 1)9 and the options are {(3360/5 + 1)9 = 6057, (3360/6 + 1)9 = 5049, (3360/7 + 1)9 = 4329, (3360/8 + 1)9 = 3789}, so S must also be one of {7, 8}. That leaves {A, U} = {5, 6}. Clue n is now U((1 + 4)3 − (A + 2)9)S = US(107 − 9A) and the four options for (A, U, S) are {(5, 6, 7), (5, 6, 8), (6, 5, 7), (6, 5, 8)}, giving the corresponding values {2604, 2976, 1855, 2120} for n. The only one without 0 or a repeat is 2976, making A = 5, U = 6 and S = 8, which only leaves O = 7.

AcrossDown
b1538c3687
i5987d1368
k2358e3789
n2976f3659
o4758j1947
p1794m2157
s1597q1594
v2316r1875
w1624t1982
y1896u2784

We can now calculate all the clue values, as shown here. For the grid entries, they need to be converted from BCEF values to G values or vice versa, using G = BE + 66CF, where the highest possible value for BE or CF is 72 = 8×9.

Starting with the lowest value, d = 1368, if we try converting it from BCEF to G we get 1×6 + 66×3×8 = 1590, which is invalid because it contains 0; so 1368 must be a G. Its CF = (1368 − BE)/66 must be between (1368 − 8×9)/66 ≈ 19.6 and (1368 − 1×2)/66 ≈ 20.7, which only allows 20, so {C, F} = {4, 5} (in either order). Then BE = 1368 − 66×4×5 = 48 and {B, E} = {6, 8}, so the entry for d is one of {6485, 6584, 8465, 8564}.

If b = 1538 is a G value then its CF is between (1538 − 8×9)/66 ≈ 22.2 and (1538 − 1×2)/66 ≈ 23.3, but 23 isn’t the product of any two digits. So 1538 is a BCEF value and we can enter b = 2643 = 1×3 + 66×5×8 in the grid, which narrows the d entry to {6485, 6584}.

There are six other clue answers that can’t be G values, as follows: j = 1947 would need CF between 28.4 and 29.5 but 29 isn’t the product of two digits, f = 3659 would need CF = 55, c = 3687 would need CF = 55, e = 3789 would need CF = 57, i = 5987 would need CF = 90; finally, s = 1597 needs CF = 24, but then BE = 1597 − 66×24 = 13, not the product of two digits. These are therefore all BCEF values, so we can calculate their G values and enter c = 2796, e = 4182, f = 3579, i = 4198, j = 4162 and s = 2319 in the grid. With b, these are the seven BCEF answers mentioned in the puzzle’s preamble, so the rest are all G values.

For the remaining clue answers, the lower and upper bounds of CF are (G − 8×9)/66 and (G − 1×2)/66 respectively, and in each case they allow either a single integer or a consecutive pair of which only one can be the product of two digits. Knowing the CF product for each answer, the BE products can also be calculated; these are listed in the second table here.

clueGCFBE
d13682048
k23583548
m21573245
n2976456
o4758726
p17942712
q15942410
r18752827
t1982302
u27844212
v2316356
w16242440
y18962848

From that, we can see that n’s BE = 6, which agrees with the first and third digits 1 and 6 we have in the grid; the other two digits have a product (CF) of 45, so they’re 5 and 9; from above (and the table) we know that d’s second and fourth digits are 4 and 5, so 5 goes where n and d cross, giving entries of d = 6485 and n = 1965.

From the grid we have k = 87__ and from the table its BE = 48 = 6×8 and CF = 35 = 5×7, so k = 8765. Similarly, o = 29__ with BE = 6 and CF = 72, so o = 2938.

The entry for m is 589_ with CF = 32, so m = 5894. Now w ends in 4 with CF = 24, so its second digit is 6, and to make BE = 40 it’s one of {5684, 8654}. u = 36__ with BE = 12 and CF = 42, so u = 3647. t starts with 2 and has BE = 2 and CF = 30, so it’s 2_1_ with 5 and 6 as the other digits; but the first digit of w can’t be 6, so t = 2516 and w = 5684.

Now y = __67 with BE = 48 and CF = 28, so y = 8467. p starts with 6 and has BE = 12 and CF = 27, so it’s one of {6329, 6923}. Then for q we have 2__8 with BE = 10 and CF = 24, so q = 2358. r ends in 4 and has CF = 28, so its second digit is 7; that makes v = 2_37 and to make its C = 35 it must be v = 2537.

For h we have __7415__, which represents G = 15__ = 7B + 66×4C. If C is 5, the second term is 66×485 = 1320, too far away to reach 1500 by adding the maximum 7B value of 63; if C is 7, we get 1848, too far away from 1599 on the high side. Therefore C = 6 and G is at least 7×1 + 66×4×6 = 1591, but that has a repeated digit; if B is 3 then 7×3 + 66×4×6 = 1605, which doesn’t match the second digit of G, so B is 2, making h = 2674 1598.

Now g is _96318__, giving G = 18__ = 6B + 66×9×3. The minimum for B is (1823 − 1782)/6 ≈ 6.8, so B is one of {7, 8} (not 9 because that would repeat a digit in the BCEF value). It can’t be 8 because 6×8 + 66×9×3 = 1830 has a 0, so B = 7 and g = 7963 1824.

For x we now have __5_142_, giving G = 142_ = 5B + 66CF. CF is between (1423 − 5×9)/66 ≈ 20.9 and (1429 − 5×1)/66 ≈ 21.6, ie CF = 21 and the second and fourth digits are {3, 7}. But r has BE = 27 with its third digit being one of {3, 9}, so now we know r = 9734, which resolves p = 6329. x is now narrowed to _753142_, with B between (1423 − 66×21)/5 = 7.4 and (1429 − 66×21)/5 = 8.6; the only possibility is B = 8, making x = 8753 1426.

The only remaining grid entry is a, matching _619357_, giving G = 357_ = 1B + 66×6×9 = B + 3564. B is at least 3571 − 3564 = 7 and it can’t be 9 because that would repeat a digit in the BCEF part. So B is one of {7, 8}, giving {76193571, 86193572} respectively for a.

Looking for a common feature shared by a, g, h and x, we may notice that the latter three have no repeated digits, and only one of the options for a shares that feature. If that’s what’s required, for the final step we need to find a fifth BCEF-G pair with eight different digits. The preamble says that the G part is greater than the ones we have so far, ie it’s > 3572. But the upper bound for G values is 7×6 + 66×9×8 = 4794. The CF we need is therefore between (3574 − 8×9)/66 ≈ 53.1 and (4793 − 1×2)/66 ≈ 72.6. The numbers in that range that are the product of two digits are {54 = 6×9, 56 = 7×8, 63 = 7×9, 72 = 8×9}. If CF is 54 then G = BE + 66×54 = BE + 3564; because 6 and 9 are the digits CF, the maximum for BE is 7×8 = 56, so G ≤ 3564 + 56 = 3620 and, to avoid repeating 6 or 9, G is in the range [3574, 3587], with BE correspondingly in the range [10, 23], being the product of two digits not including 3 or 5 (which are in G) or 6 or 9 (which are C and F). The only such values are {14 = 2×7, 16 = 2×8}, but 2×7 + 66×6×9 = 3578 repeats 7 and 2×8 + 66×6×9 = 3580 repeats 8 (and has a disallowed 0); therefore CF isn’t 54.

If CF is 56 then G = BE + 3696; because 7 and 8 are the digits CF, the maximum for BE is 9×6 = 54, so G ≤ 3696 + 54 = 3750. G is ≥ 3696 + 1×2 = 3698 but in the range [3698, 3750] the only value that doesn’t contain 7 or 8 or is 3699, with a repeated 9; therefore CF isn’t 56.

If CF is 72 then G = BE + 4752; because 8 and 9 are the digits CF, the maximum for BE is 7×6 = 42, so G ≤ 4752 + 42 = 4794, but because it can’t repeat 9, 8 or 7 its upper bound is 4765. G is ≥ 4752 + 1×2 = 4754, so it’s in the range [4754, 4765]; the only values in that range that don’t contain 8, 9, 0 or a repeated digit are {4756, 4761, 4762, 4763, 4765} with corresponding BE values of {4, 9, 10, 11, 13}, from which we can eliminate 4 = 1×4 (we have a 4 in G), 9 = 1×9 (either C or F is 9) and the primes 11 and 13. If BE is 10 = 2×5 then G = 4762, which repeats a 2; therefore CF isn’t 72.

So we’re left with CF = 63 = 7×9, making G = BE + 4158. The maximum available for BE is 6×8 = 48, so G ≤ 4158 + 48 = 4206, but it’s not allowed to contain 0 (or 7 or 9), so the maximum comes down to 4186; BE can’t include 1 (or 4) because that would be repeated in G, so the minimum for G is 4158 + 2×3 = 4164. The only values in the range [4164, 4186] without 0, 7, 9 or repeats are {4165, 4168, 4182, 4183, 4185, 4186}, with corresponding BE values of {7, 10, 24, 25, 27, 28}. We can eliminate 7 = 1×7, 25 = 5×5, 27 = 3×9 and 28 = 4×7 because they repeat digits. If BE is 24 we have G = 24 + 4158 = 4182, but then either 3×8 or 4×6 for BE would repeat a digit in G. Therefore BE = 10 = 2×5 and G = 4168. There are four permutations of the BE and CF digits, namely {2759, 2957, 5729, 5927}, but the preamble says we want the smallest one, so the required numbers are 2759 and 4168. Converting those to the letters used in clues gives ROAD INUS (“in US”), a description of the famous Route 66 hinted at by the puzzle’s title.

Back to 2023 menu